Gas grills win on convenience; fire pit grills win on flavor and ambiance.
Here is how they compare.
The Outdoor Recreation is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Quick Picks
- Top pick: 3-in-1 Round Wood Burning Fire Pit with Grill
- Best Solo Stove grill add-on: Solo Stove Large Cast Iron Grill Top
- Best griddle: Blackstone 22 in Tabletop Griddle
- Best camp stove: Coleman Classic Propane Camping Stove
- Top pick: Breeo Portable Smokeless Fire Pit
Comparison Table
| Product | Best for | Type | Standout feature | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3-in-1 Round Wood Burning Fire Pit with Grill | Top pick | Fire pit + grill | Lid and poker | View |
| Solo Stove Large Cast Iron Grill Top | Best Solo Stove grill add-on | Cast iron grate | Fits Bonfire and Yukon | View |
| Blackstone 22 in Tabletop Griddle | Best griddle | 22 in griddle | Propane | View |
| Coleman Classic Propane Camping Stove | Best camp stove | 22,000 BTU | Two burners | View |
| Breeo Portable Smokeless Fire Pit | Top pick | About 31 lb | Smokeless | View |
Detailed Reviews
1This 3-in-1 fire pit works as a fire pit, a grill with a cooking grate and a table with its lid.
It includes a fire poker and suits backyard cooking.
Pros & Cons
What we like
- Grill grate included
- Lid doubles as table
- Good value
Watch out for
- Steel needs care
- Generic brand
Key Specs
- Use: fire pit, grill, table
- Includes: lid, poker
- Fuel: wood
2. Solo Stove Large Cast Iron Grill Top
2This cast iron grill top turns a Solo Stove Bonfire or Yukon into a wood-fired grill.
It is the easiest way to cook over a smokeless fire pit.
Pros & Cons
What we like
- Turns pit into grill
- Cast iron sear
- Solid fit
Watch out for
- Heavy
- Needs hub for some setups
Key Specs
- Material: cast iron
- Fit: Bonfire, Yukon (per listing)
- Use: grilling
3The Blackstone 22-inch tabletop griddle is a portable propane flat-top for breakfasts, smash burgers and camp meals.
It is the classic comparison point for fire pit grills.
Pros & Cons
What we like
- Big flat cooking area
- Portable
- Even heat
Watch out for
- Propane only
- Not a campfire
Key Specs
- Size: 22 in
- Fuel: propane
- Type: tabletop griddle
4The Coleman Classic two-burner propane stove is a camping staple with wind guards and adjustable burners.
Pair it with a fire pit when you want fast, controllable cooking.
Pros & Cons
What we like
- Reliable
- Wind guards
- Affordable
Watch out for
- Not a fire pit
- Needs propane
Key Specs
- Burners: 2
- Power: 22,000 BTU total
- Fuel: propane
5This Breeo fire pit is a portable smokeless design for families who want a clean-burning fire at home or camp.
Breeo is known for durable steel fire pits and cooking accessories.
Pros & Cons
What we like
- Smokeless
- Durable steel
- Portable size
Watch out for
- Premium price
- Accessories sold separately
Key Specs
- Weight: about 31 lb
- Design: smokeless
- Fuel: wood
How We Chose
We compared grate material, cooking area, height adjustment, stability and fit across fire pit grills, grates and griddles, then read verified owner feedback on cooking results and durability. We did not receive free products, and we do not claim hands-on testing. TOR Scores combine published specs, verified owner feedback and overall value. You may also find our guide to the best fire pit vs gas helpful.
Fire Pit Grill vs Griddle vs Gas Grill
A fire pit grill cooks over wood or charcoal for smoky flavor and doubles as a campfire. A griddle such as a Blackstone uses propane and a flat steel top for breakfasts, smash burgers and stir-fries. A gas grill offers precise, fast heat with less cleanup. Many campers bring a fire pit for evenings and a griddle or stove for fast meals.
Wood, Propane or Natural Gas?
- Wood: crackle, more radiant heat and campfire cooking; needs wood storage and cleanup.
- Propane: instant on and off, no sparks, portable; tanks need refilling.
- Natural gas: no tanks to swap, but needs a gas line installed by a professional.
If you love cooking and campfire ambiance, choose wood. If you want convenience on a patio or deck, propane or natural gas is easier.
Cleaning and Caring for a Fire Pit Grill
Let the fire die and the grate cool, then brush off residue and empty the ash. Season cast iron with a thin coat of oil, store grates dry and cover the fire pit between uses. Inspect legs and welds each season, especially on budget grill combos. Related: our shortlist of the best fire pit with grill.
Fire Pit Grill Grates Explained
A grate turns a fire pit into a grill. Cast iron grates hold heat and sear well but are heavy; stainless steel grates are lighter and rust-resistant. Adjustable or swing-away grates let you control heat by changing the distance from the coals, and some grates have leveling legs for uneven ground. Clean grates with a brush while warm and oil cast iron to prevent rust.
Choosing Firewood
Burn seasoned hardwood such as oak, maple or hickory for hotter, cleaner fires with less smoke. Seasoned wood is dry, lighter and often has cracked ends. Wet or green wood smokes heavily, pops and leaves more soot.
Never burn treated lumber, painted wood, trash or plastics. Buy or gather firewood locally where required, because moving firewood can spread invasive pests. If you are comparing options, our guide to the best fire pit grill is worth a look.
Fire Pit Care and Rust Prevention
Empty ash once it is completely cold, because wet ash holds moisture against steel and speeds up rust. Cover the pit or store it under shelter between uses, and touch up chipped paint on painted steel pits with high-heat paint.
Stainless steel resists rust best but can still discolor with heat, which is normal. Cast iron lasts well when kept dry and lightly oiled.
Cooking on a Chiminea
Many chimineas can double as a small outdoor grill, especially models with a built-in grill grate or an open front. Let the fire burn down to hot coals before cooking, and use hardwood rather than softwood for better flavor and less soot. For a different angle, see our picks for the best chiminea for backyard.
- Use long-handled tools and heat-proof gloves.
- Cast iron and steel chimineas handle cooking heat better than clay.
- Clean grease off the grate after each use so it does not flare up next time.
- Do not use painted or treated wood, which can give off harmful fumes.
Cooking Over a Fire Pit
Let the fire burn down to hot coals before cooking. Use a sturdy grate, cast iron pans or a Dutch oven, and keep long-handled tools and heat-resistant gloves nearby. Check meat with a thermometer and never leave cooking fires unattended. For a closer look, see our guide to the best fire pit grill for camping.
Check Local Fire Rules
Many cities, counties and parks restrict open burning during dry or windy weather. Check local rules and any burn bans before each fire, and follow campground regulations when camping.
Keep water or an extinguisher nearby, never leave a fire unattended and put it out completely before you leave or go to bed. Smokey Bear’s campfire guidance in our sources is a good checklist.
Related guides: best fire pit grill vs blackstone, best fire pit grill vs griddle, best fire pit grill vs grill. See every pick in our Fire Pits category.
Sources and further reading: NFPA: safety with heating equipment, CDC: carbon monoxide poisoning basics and Smokey Bear: campfire safety. Product details come from brand listings on Amazon. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions and local burn rules.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you grill on a fire pit?
Yes, with a grate or grill top over hot coals.
Is a griddle better than a fire pit grill?
A griddle is faster and easier; a fire pit grill gives smoky flavor and a campfire.
Can you cook on a fire pit?
Yes with a grate or cast iron; wait for hot coals and keep tools long-handled.
How far should a fire pit be from the house?
Often at least 10 feet, but follow the maker’s instructions and local codes.
Are smokeless fire pits really smokeless?
They greatly reduce smoke once the fire is hot, but some smoke still occurs when lighting and adding wood.
Final Verdict
Pick a fire pit grill if you want a campfire too.






Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!